Last updated: November 20, 2026
Substack is the better choice for writers who want to build a direct relationship with readers, own their email list and earn money from paid subscriptions. Medium is the better choice for writers who want built-in reach from Medium’s existing readership and a simple way to earn through the Partner Program without marketing their own newsletter.
Substack Vs Medium At A Glance
| Feature | Substack | Medium |
|---|---|---|
| Model | Newsletter and publication you own | Shared publishing platform |
| Cost to publish | Free | Free |
| How writers earn | Paid subscriptions you set | Partner Program payments based on member engagement |
| Platform cut | 10% of paid subscription revenue plus card fees | No direct cut; earnings come from Medium’s member pool |
| Email list | Yes, exportable | Followers can get email, but no list export of the same kind |
| Discovery | Recommendations, Notes and the app | Algorithmic feeds, tags and publications |
| Formats | Posts, podcasts, video, chat and Notes | Articles |
| Custom domain | Yes, one-time fee | Limited |
| Best for | Building an owned audience and income | Reaching readers quickly with minimal setup |
Earning Money
Substack lets writers turn on paid subscriptions at a price they choose. Substack keeps 10% of subscription revenue, and Stripe charges card processing. Writers with loyal audiences can earn predictable monthly income, and they keep the customer relationship.
Medium pays writers in the Partner Program based on how paying Medium members engage with their stories, including reading time and interactions. Earnings can be meaningful for prolific writers but are less predictable and depend on Medium’s rules.
Verdict: Substack wins for sustainable, writer-controlled income.
Audience Ownership
On Substack, every subscriber’s email address belongs to the writer, and the list can be exported to another platform at any time. That makes a Substack audience portable.
On Medium, followers are tied to the platform. If Medium changes its algorithm or payment rules, writers have less control over reaching their readers.
Verdict: Substack wins on ownership.
Discovery And Reach
Medium’s biggest advantage is its built-in readership. Good stories can be distributed to many readers through tags, publications and recommendations, even for brand-new writers.
Substack’s discovery has grown through recommendations between newsletters, the Substack app and Notes, a social feed. Still, most writers grow their Substack by bringing readers from social media, search and other channels.
Verdict: Medium wins for fast reach.
Writing And Publishing Tools
Both offer clean, distraction-free editors. Substack adds podcasts, video, community chat, scheduled emails and a customizable publication homepage. Medium keeps things simple, focused on articles, with publications for group blogs.
SEO
Medium has strong domain authority, so its articles can rank in search, but the traffic builds Medium’s brand. Substack posts can rank too, and a custom domain helps writers build search value for their own brand.
Pros And Cons
Substack pros: you own your email list, flexible paid subscriptions, podcasts and community features, custom domains.
Substack cons: 10% cut of paid revenue, growth often depends on your own marketing.
Medium pros: built-in readership, simple publishing, earning without running a subscription business.
Medium cons: less audience ownership, unpredictable earnings, rules can change.
Which Should You Choose?
Choose Substack if you want to build a long-term audience and earn from paid subscriptions.
Choose Medium if you want readers quickly and prefer writing to marketing.
Many writers do both: they publish on Medium for reach and link readers to a Substack newsletter.
How We Researched This Guide
We reviewed each platform’s published creator terms, payment models and feature documentation, then compared them on earning potential, audience ownership, discovery and publishing tools. Terms can change, so check each platform’s current policies.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much does Substack take?
Substack keeps 10% of paid subscription revenue, and Stripe charges separate card processing fees. Free newsletters cost nothing.
How does Medium pay writers?
Through the Partner Program, which pays based on how paying Medium members engage with your stories.
Can I export my audience?
On Substack, yes: you can export your subscriber list. Medium does not offer the same portability.
Conclusion
Substack is the best platform for writers building an owned audience and subscription income. Medium is the best platform for quick reach with minimal setup. Choose based on whether ownership or reach matters more right now.
