Last updated: November 20, 2026
Zeffy is the better choice for registered nonprofits that want to keep 100% of every donation, because it charges no platform fee and covers card processing itself. Givebutter is the better choice for organizations that need a stronger built-in CRM, more integrations, text-to-give or eligibility beyond nonprofits, such as schools, teams and community groups. Both platforms are free to start and fund themselves through optional contributions from donors.
This guide compares Givebutter and Zeffy on fees, features, donor experience, eligibility and reporting so you can pick the right platform for your next campaign.
Givebutter Vs Zeffy At A Glance
| Feature | Givebutter | Zeffy |
|---|---|---|
| Platform fee | 0% with donor tips on; 3% with tips off | 0% |
| Card processing | Covered by donors when tips are on; 2.9% + $0.30 with tips off | 0%, covered by Zeffy |
| How it earns money | Optional donor tips | Optional donor contributions |
| Who can use it | Nonprofits, schools, teams, clubs and other groups | Registered nonprofits in the US and Canada |
| Donor CRM | Full built-in CRM with segments and history | Basic donor management |
| Text-to-give | Yes | Limited |
| Events and ticketing | Yes | Yes |
| Auctions and raffles | Yes | Yes |
| Integrations | Many, including Zapier and QuickBooks | Fewer |
| Best for | Growing teams that want an all-in-one system | Small nonprofits that want zero fees |
Fees: Who Really Pays
Fees are the main reason people compare these two platforms.
Zeffy charges organizations nothing. There is no platform fee, no transaction fee and no card processing fee. Zeffy absorbs processing costs and asks donors for an optional contribution at checkout. Donors can lower that contribution to zero, and the nonprofit still receives the full gift.
Givebutter also charges no platform fee as long as donor tips are switched on. Donors see an optional tip and can choose to cover processing. If an organization turns tips off, it pays a 3% platform fee plus standard card processing of 2.9% + $0.30 per transaction. On a $10,000 campaign with tips off, that can mean several hundred dollars in fees.
Verdict: Zeffy wins on fees. If guaranteed 100% of gifts matters most, it is the safer choice.
Features And Fundraising Tools
Both platforms cover the core tools most nonprofits need:
- Donation forms and branded campaign pages
- Recurring monthly giving
- Event registration and ticketing
- Peer-to-peer fundraising pages
- Auctions and raffles
- Membership forms
Givebutter goes further. Its built-in CRM stores donor profiles, giving history, notes and segments, and it can send email and text messages from the same dashboard. Text-to-give, live streaming, a donor wall and a deeper integration library make it closer to a complete fundraising operating system.
Zeffy keeps every feature free, regardless of organization size, and covers most of what a small team needs. Its donor management is simpler, and it has fewer third-party integrations.
Verdict: Givebutter wins on depth of features.
Donor Experience
The checkout flow shapes how donors feel about your organization. On both platforms, donors see an optional contribution or tip at checkout. Some donors find these prompts confusing, especially if the default amount is high. Both platforms let donors change the amount, and nonprofits should tell supporters that the contribution is optional.
Givebutter pages tend to feel more customizable, with video, live streams and social sharing built in. Zeffy pages are clean and quick to set up, which suits volunteer-run organizations.
Eligibility
This is often the deciding factor. Zeffy is built only for registered nonprofits in the United States and Canada. Givebutter serves a wider range of organizations, including schools, PTAs, sports teams, clubs and community groups. Neither platform is built for individuals raising money for personal causes. For that, see our comparison of GoFundMe and GiveSendGo and our list of GoFundMe alternatives.
Payouts And Reporting
Both platforms pay out to the organization’s bank account and provide donation receipts for tax purposes. Givebutter offers more detailed reporting and exports through its CRM, which helps development teams track donor retention and campaign performance. Zeffy provides the reports most small nonprofits need, including tax receipts and transaction exports.
Pros And Cons
Givebutter pros: strong CRM, text-to-give, many integrations, open to schools, teams and groups, highly customizable pages.
Givebutter cons: a 3% platform fee plus processing if tips are turned off; more features means more setup time.
Zeffy pros: no fees for nonprofits, every feature free, fast setup, simple for volunteers.
Zeffy cons: nonprofits in the US and Canada only, lighter CRM, fewer integrations.
Which Should You Choose?
Choose Zeffy if you are a registered nonprofit in the US or Canada, your team is small, and keeping every dollar is the top priority.
Choose Givebutter if you need a full donor CRM, text-to-give and integrations, or if you are a school, team or community group that Zeffy does not serve.
Many organizations start on Zeffy to keep costs at zero and move to Givebutter when their donor base and team grow.
How We Researched This Guide
We reviewed each platform’s published pricing, fee pages, feature documentation and eligibility rules, then compared the donor checkout flow and the tools available to organizations of different sizes. We focused on the total cost to the organization and the features nonprofits use most.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Zeffy really free?
For nonprofits, yes. Zeffy charges no platform or processing fees and funds itself through optional contributions donors add at checkout, which donors can set to zero.
Does Givebutter charge a fee?
Givebutter charges no platform fee when donor tips are enabled. If an organization turns tips off, it pays a 3% platform fee plus card processing of 2.9% + $0.30.
Can individuals use Givebutter or Zeffy?
Neither is built for personal fundraising. Zeffy serves registered nonprofits only, and Givebutter serves organizations and groups rather than individuals.
Which is better for schools and sports teams?
Givebutter, because it accepts schools, PTAs, teams and clubs. Zeffy is limited to registered nonprofits.
Conclusion
Zeffy is the best choice for small registered nonprofits that want zero fees. Givebutter is the best choice for organizations that need a full CRM, more integrations or eligibility beyond nonprofits. Both are free to start, so many teams test each with a small campaign before committing.
